[These thoughts are backdated up to the publication of Naruto 366, but much of what is discussed here still applies.]
Well, if all of the suspicious panels that Masashi Kishimoto was giving us of Itachi’s sexy face weren’t enough up until now, 366 confirms that there really is more to the declared sociopath than meets the eye. As an “author” or “character creator” myself, I suspected early on from the Sasuke’s detailed flashbacks of his brother and the fact that Itachi killed his entire clan that Kishimoto was intentionally misleading people into believing that Itachi is such a straightforward character. Good authors rarely do that. At least ones with this kind of lengthy, detailed plot.
Itachi uses a shadow clone to confront Naruto, wishing only to speak with the latter even though his objective thus far has been to capture Naruto and take the Kyuubi, thereby killing him as a side affect. The “supposed” Akatsuki leader has already made it clear that Itachi needs to get busy with his appointed mission.
But there are many things that are off about Itachi due to things he has said and illogical stories. The fact that he wishes to only “speak” with Naruto in this chapter confirms what evidence already exists.
First of all, there is the issue of him killing his entire clan. Some people have already gone so far as to say he didn’t do it, but I do not believe that this is the case. However, I am of the opinion that he wasn’t alone for several reasons.
1. How the hell did he manage to kill everybody in the clan, all in one night, without anyone finding out before he finished? It’s not like they were all sitting in the same room, and is it even possible that none of them were away on missions or in places where other ninja could have easily come to their aid. They were the friggin’ Konoha police force. If something like a family gathering had occurred at the time, why on earth would Kishimoto neglect to mention that? Furthermore, they were all Uchiha, and he had only recently acquired the powerful Mangekyou Sharingan, and being new to it, plus the fact that even now using it on one person is draining, there’s no way the Uchiha couldn’t have put up a good enough fight that somehow wouldn’t alert other people in Konoha. I don’t care if Itachi is the Uchiha genius; if he was good enough to kill an entire clan of Uchiha’s in one night, there is no reason why he couldn’t have defeated and/or killed Kakashi and everyone else he has since encountered.
2. Although the exact time of his entrance into Akatsuki is unclear, evidence suggests that it was around the time that he acquired the Mangekyou Sharingan and killed his clan. It is highly possible that killing the clan was the prerequisite to entering the organization. However, does that mean that he couldn’t be aided slightly in the process. Furthermore, the recent revelation of Tobi also being an Uchiha could suggest that perhaps he wanted the clan dead as well. If this is the case, and if Itachi had already joined Akatsuki before the massacre, then perhaps he was given aid in the task.
The next suspicious piece of information is his reason for keeping Sasuke alive.
Suppose, at the time of the massacre, he did it because he believed that Sasuke was the only person who could ever hope to be on equally footing with him. Itachi claims that he killed his clan to “test his ability” (which could, in fact, be another indication that this was the test he was require to pass before becoming Akatsuki). If he really did it for this reason, then it would make sense that he might have left Sasuke alive at the time in order to have another challenge to test himself some day in the future. Therefore, he encourages Sasuke to come after him. To him, this is all a matter of growing his power.
Either that, or he really is the Master Mindfuck.
But, okay, let’s go back to his belief that Sasuke might be the only person to stand on equal footing with him. Um, okay, if he really believed that then, there is no reason for him to continue believing that years later when he meets Sasuke again. Why? I find it hard to believe the man is cocky enough to think that there is no one in Akatsuki stronger than him. I suppose he could believe it, and he simply follows orders because he is not one to play leader or he simply agrees with the organization’s purpose and doesn’t give a damn if someone less powerful is in charge. But if he really is out to increase his power, would he not have bothered to investigate other members and decide who to next challenge? If he found someone more powerful than him, why wait for Sasuke to catch up? There are other goals. No reason to keep Sasuke around anymore.
He seems genuine in his desire for Sasuke to become strong enough some day to kill him. The way he encourages Sasuke to do this, I think, is merely a result of Itachi’s own true beliefs about life, as well as the desire for Sasuke not lose his wish for vengence. Itachi truly appears to have a death wish. Of course, here some people might say, “Well why doesn’t he just kill himself?” Two answers: one, being who he is, Itachi may see the only suitable death for himself is one by the hand of another Uchiha, and his brother most of all. Two, I think he intends to die, but not until he has executed some plan of his own.
Yes, I believe Itachi has a plan. I don’t know whether it is simply for himself or for Konoha or everybody, but I believe he has one. There are several reasons for this. First of all, it’s somewhat apparent that although Akatsuki is an effective team of ninja, each of the members has his or her own reason for joining, and somehow being part of Akatsuki furthers their individual goals. (Although, the flashback showing how Deidara forced to join seems an exception). I am curious as to whether or not Itachi agrees with their philosophy, but regardless it seems natural that he has his own plans as well. Perhaps they are straightfoward and he simply wishes to be part of something powerful. But other facts negate this as his main reason. The fact that he continues to leave Sasuke alive, and his disgrutled (or at least as far as Kishimoto’s panels will suggest) by the thought of Sasuke’s death.
But the things that eats away at me are his dealings with Naruto. Thus far, he has only made one attempt in the entirety of the series to capture the Kyuubi, and he quickly gave up on it in order to prevent a mess, as we remember in part 1. Then, when Kisame talks about the situation, he says that because the Kyuubi must be sealed last, why bother going after Naruto until the time is upon them? Again, he avoids taking initiative with Naruto. It feels like he is putting it off on purpose. Perhaps the whole thing simply seems logical to him, but the recent chapter 366 suggests otherwise. He has something he wishes to speak with Naruto about. Perhaps this desire to talk is only the result of recent happenings, but I’m thinking it could very well be otherwise, or that he has been hesitant to capture Naruto for some time now.
The chapter ends with him leaving Naruto alone and facing his brother. I’m questioning whether or not this really is Itachi that Sasuke is facing, and, if it is, if Itachi won’t purposely seek some means of escape. He calmly left Naruto as though they would have the chance to speak another time, which suggests that he does not intend, or he does not believe, he will die in his current encounter with Sasuke. There is also the fact that he is alone, without Kisame, or at least as near as we can tell. Beyond that, Pein has already told him to be on alert. Unless Itachi and Kisame are truly loyal companions, more so than they are loyal to the organization, which in itself seems highly unlikely, there is no reason for Kisame to leave is partner at this time or allow Itachi to get caught up in a personal quarrel.
What could he want to talk to Naruto about? It seems unlikely that it would not be something important. He doesn’t seem to the type to make an encounter with the sole purpose of talking and quelling his curiosity. Sure, perhaps he might do that, but he might do that and then kill Naruto too, once satisfied.
There are a bunch of questions we have to ask. First of all, why does he actually want Sasuke alive? Why does he want to talk to Naruto? Was his encounter in the forest with Naruto “off the books” with the other Akatsuki? Finally, and most importantly, I believe, is the question of whether or not he is aware of the existence of a third Uchiha, and if he knows that Uchiha is involved with the organization.
I mentioned in a previous entry that my suspicion is that he IS aware. 1. He says that IF Sasuke acquires the Mangekyou, there will be three people capable of using it. As I said before, this suggests he is not talking about potential, as they will only become three IF Sasuke acquires it. Even if he only suspected Sasuke’s ability, and was basing his words off of suspicion, then he would have to do the same for the third person as well. This means that he could not confirm, as his statement seems to do, that there would be THREE people. The other person would have to be a gamble as well. This means that there is someone else who can already actively use it. Which also means Kakashi is ruled out, because Kakashi did not have the ability at the time Itachi said this. Therefore, I conclude (based on translations) that Itachi MUST know there is another Uchiha/ someone with an Uchiha eye, around. To what extent he is aware of that Uchiha’s involvement with everything is questionable.
Now we have to wonder if everything he has done this far is a result of his interaction, direct or indirect, with Tobi. Indirect would mean orders were passed down from Pein. Nonetheless, regardless of who he gets his orders from, that doesn’t mean he isn’t suspicious or aware. I especially think this because of Tobi’s interest in Sasuke’s eyes, which will surpass Itachi’s. Perhaps leaving Sasuke alive with part of his orders years ago.
His talk with Naruto now raises several other important questions. By the way the encounter goes, it seems as though he acting independently from the Akatsuki, but it is not clear if this signifies he is a traitor, if he is simply acting on his own plans, or if he still wishes to aid Akatsuki despite his own interests. Whose side is Itachi really on, and why?
While Itachi isn’t my favorite character in the series, he is definitely the most fascinating, even with the recent revelations about Pein, the unnamed member, and Tobi.
It’s late. I’m going to bed.